I’m probably one of the most indecisive people I know.
Part of it is overthinking. Part of it is ADHD. Then there’s over-optimization. Throw in some perfectionism, a sprinkle of external pressure, and a tiny dusting of self-doubt, and there you have it: a few more minutes, hours, or even days spent in analysis paralysis and decision fatigue instead of moving forward with grace, ease, and peace.
Eek.
Somewhere along the way of writing and thinking about relationships, I’ve realized something: So much of it comes down to choices. And I strive to help people make more intentional, authentic, and aligned choices so they can date and relate with greater ease. I’ve also learned just how important trying less can be, even in my own 12+ year relationship.
But the irony is that, while I’ve gotten pretty good at applying this philosophy to relationships, I haven’t always been able to make clear, intentional choices in other areas of my life.
I could decide whether to share a deep, dark secret with my husband or have a difficult conversation with a new friend without nearly as much deliberation as it took me to decide what I wanted to eat for dinner or whether I should start a new workout plan.
Something had to give.
So, in true Same New Love fashion (i.e., “I deserve better than this current reality, and I’m going to do something about it”), I decided to dig through the depths of my soul. Or, at least, my memory bank:
I started thinking about the pivotal personal decisions I’d made over the years, big and small, that had changed the trajectory of my life, my circumstances, or even my mindset.
Things like leaving religion, choosing one university over another, quitting a well-paying job, traveling across the world, and so on.
What did these decisions have in common? How did I arrive at them? What did I consider, prioritize, question, and ultimately rely on to make them?
I wanted to identify the overarching themes across what seemed like completely unrelated situations.
And as I started connecting the dots, I realized something: I actually did have a decision-making system. It just wasn’t one I’d ever formally articulated.
There were recurring elements: understanding what I could control, gathering relevant information, separating fact from fiction, identifying my values, and learning to trust my eventual choices.
What if I could turn all of that into a simple, repeatable, and memorable method?
And so, the FourCight Method was born!
Okay, yeah, great question.
At its core, Same New Love has always been about questioning inherited rules and creating relationships that actually fit. It’s about recognizing how much of what we think we want, what we prioritize, and how we behave in relationships has been shaped by external expectations rather than our own genuine preferences.
Consider the decisions we make when dating:
Who should I go on a date with? What should I wear? How much should I prioritize financial stability? Should I give someone another chance? Am I being too picky? Am I asking for too much?
It’s remarkably easy to let societal standards, family expectations, dating advice, and other people’s opinions influence these decisions, sometimes without even realizing it.
My general advice? Be careful about outsourcing these decisions to anyone else.
Not because other people can’t offer valuable perspectives, but because you’re the one who has to live with the consequences. Your preferences, values, circumstances, and priorities matter in ways that no generic set of dating rules can fully account for.
What happens after you stop letting the world make decisions for you?
What happens when you reject the conventional rules but haven’t developed a reliable way to figure out what you actually want?
In other words, if you stop outsourcing your decision-making to society, your family, your friends, or the internet, how do you get better at making decisions for yourself?
And how do you avoid replacing external pressure with a complete lack of direction?
That’s where I think the FourCight Method can help.
The FourCight Method is a four-step decision-making framework I’ve developed to help me think through personal decisions without unnecessarily overthinking them or outsourcing my judgment.
It’s absolutely not a set of rules you have to follow, nor am I suggesting that it’s the only or universally correct way to make decisions. Think of it as a framework to test, adapt, and use when you need a little more structure in your decision-making.
I’ve boiled down my approach into four main steps:
Control. Clarity. Compass. Confidence.
The idea is to work through four fundamental elements of a decision so that you’re less inclined to default to chance, the status quo, what everyone else is doing, or, increasingly, even what AI tells you to do.
To make the method easier to understand, I’ll use three examples throughout:
Three very different decisions, but the same four steps can help you work through all of them.
Have you ever spent hours (or days) agonizing over a decision, only to eventually realize that it wasn’t entirely yours to make in the first place?
Or perhaps that you were worrying about something you had very little control over?
That’s why Control comes first.
The first question is simple: Is this your decision to make?
From there, you can consider what aspects of the decision you actually control, what you don’t, and how reversible the decision might be.
This distinction matters because we often take on unnecessary responsibility for decisions that involve other people, circumstances, or outcomes beyond our control.
Let’s look at our three examples.
If you’re eating alone, the decision is probably yours. But if you’re deciding where to go with a group of friends, is it really your responsibility to choose for everyone?
Perhaps you could share the responsibility, ask everyone for their preferences, or let someone else decide this time.
Control is also about how easy it may or may not be to reverse the decision. Choosing a restaurant in an area with plenty of alternatives is relatively low-risk. Driving an hour to a restaurant with no other options nearby is a little less so.
You can control whether you’re interested in seeing someone again, whether you communicate that interest, and whether you make yourself available for another date.
You cannot control whether the other person likes you, whether they’re interested in pursuing something serious, or whether the relationship will eventually work out.
And importantly, you don’t need to make a decision about the entire future of a relationship just because you’re deciding whether to go on a second date.
The decision at hand is simply whether you want another date. That’s it.
Unknowingly, this concept of “Control” has come in handy in many areas of this work. For example, when a woman has asked, “Should he text me back by now?” I pointed out that that’s not a decision she has control over. So the question shifts to “Should I text him right now?” and even better, “Do I want to text him right now?”
You can control whether you explore other opportunities, assess your finances, prepare an exit strategy, and ultimately decide whether to resign.
However, you may have less control over whether your employer offers a raise, how quickly you find another job, or how the job market develops.
Also, consider reversibility. Leaving a job without another source of income may be more consequential than negotiating a change in responsibilities or taking some time to explore alternatives before making a final decision.
The point of Control isn’t to guarantee a particular outcome, but to understand where your actual decision-making power begins and ends.
Sometimes, that’s enough to make a seemingly overwhelming decision feel considerably more manageable.
Once you’ve established that the decision is yours to make (or reconstructed the question to ensure that you’re focused on the part that is), it’s time to get some clarity.
This step is about understanding the relevant information, assumptions, and beliefs that should inform your decision.
I often find myself getting unnecessarily stressed about whether something will be a “good” choice. But sometimes, that stress is simply a symptom of not having enough information or not knowing which information actually matters.
So, Clarity has two important components.
First: Gather relevant information.
What do you need to know to make an informed decision?
You don’t necessarily need every possible piece of information. In fact, trying to acquire every last detail can become another form of overthinking.
Instead, identify the information that could genuinely change or inform your decision.
Second: Separate fact from fiction.
This is about examining your concerns and determining whether they’re based on evidence, assumptions, interpretations, or fear.
Not every thought or concern is a fact. And not every belief is necessarily false. The important thing is understanding the difference so you can evaluate each appropriately.
Let’s revisit our examples.
You might initially want to base your decision on how you’re feeling in the moment. But what else could be relevant?
What’s available? What’s on the menu? What are the prices? How far away is the restaurant? What do the reviews say?
You might also need to question some of your assumptions.
For example, assuming that an expensive restaurant automatically has better food isn’t necessarily supported by anything beyond your own perception.
And here’s something I find particularly interesting: Simply identifying what information you want to know can reveal what you’re actually prioritizing in the decision.
Are you looking for the healthiest option? The cheapest? The most convenient? The most exciting?
But okay I’m getting carried away, as that leans into values, and we’ll get to that in the next step!
What do you actually know about this person and your experience together?
Did you enjoy the conversation? Did you feel comfortable? Were you genuinely interested in getting to know them? Did they demonstrate qualities that matter to you?
Do you know enough or do you need (and want) to know more?
And then, you can consider the difference between facts and interpretations.
Fact: They didn’t text you the morning after the first date.
Interpretation: They’re not interested in you.
Fact: They expressed a different opinion about something important to you.
Interpretation: You’re fundamentally incompatible.
Neither interpretation is necessarily wrong, but neither is automatically established by the facts. Instead, those interpretations can be based simply on underlying fear or doubt.
Clarity encourages you to distinguish what actually happened from the meaning you’ve assigned to it, and to recognize when you need more information before drawing conclusions.
Here, information gathering might involve reviewing your finances, understanding your current employment benefits, researching other opportunities, assessing your career prospects, and considering what your next steps might look like.
You might also want to examine some of the beliefs driving your decision.
Fact: You’ve been unhappy in your current role for six months.
Belief: I’ll never find another job that pays this well.
Fact: Your manager has repeatedly declined your requests for additional flexibility.
Belief: Leaving a stable job means I’m being irresponsible.
The beliefs might contain some truth, depending on the real circumstances, but they deserve to be truly examined rather than automatically accepted.
Sometimes, the difference between feeling completely stuck and feeling ready to move forward is simply knowing what’s true, what’s uncertain, and what you’ve been assuming.
I think and write a lot about value-based decision-making, and this is where that philosophy comes into play. Unsurprisingly, it’s my favorite step!!
Compass is about identifying the values and priorities that matter most to you in the context of a particular decision.
But disclaimer: Not every value needs to be equally important in every situation. And not every decision needs to optimize for everything you care about.
And sometimes, of course, you may have competing priorities. Sometimes, you need to make a trade-off. And sometimes, the most important thing is recognizing which values you actually want to prioritize right now.
But overall, this step is where you can begin evaluating your options against those priorities rather than simply choosing whichever option looks best according to someone else’s standards.
If health is your primary consideration, your decision might look different than if you’re prioritizing pleasure, convenience, affordability, or novelty.
Perhaps you want something nutritious today. Perhaps you’ve had a stressful week and would rather prioritize enjoyment.
Neither is inherently the better choice. It depends on what matters to you (either in that moment or for a commitment you’ve made to yourself). Even for something seemingly “small” like what to eat, just pausing to consider what matters most is beneficial in the long run.
Should I go on a second date?
What are you actually looking for in a dating experience or potential partner?
Maybe you prioritize emotional availability, curiosity, shared values, physical attraction, a sense of humor, or cultural compatibility.
You might also need to consider how much weight you’re giving to things that don’t actually matter as much to you as you’ve been led to believe.
For example, are you rejecting someone because you genuinely don’t feel compatible, or because they don’t fit an arbitrary checklist you’ve inherited about what a suitable partner should look like?
And conversely, are you overlooking something important because someone looks great on paper?
Compass helps you distinguish between what you genuinely value and what you’ve simply been conditioned to prioritize.
Should I quit my job?
Perhaps you value financial security, flexibility, professional growth, autonomy, meaningful work, or time outside of work.
These values might compete with one another.
A higher-paying job might offer less flexibility. A career change might provide more meaning but require a temporary reduction in income.
The question isn’t necessarily which option is objectively best. It’s which trade-offs you’re willing to make based on what matters most to you at this stage of your life.
The Compass stage helps you identify what you’re actually moving toward, rather than simply what you’re trying to escape.
Finally, we arrive at Confidence.
This step is about explicitly making your decision and feeling comfortable enough to commit to it.
I went back and forth in my mind on whether this was even necessary. But upon reflecting on my past decisions, especially the ones I’m most proud of, there always seems to be a moment where I consciously said “yes.” And those moments – that conscious commitment- feel important for not executing the decision, but minimizing future regret.
But I want to emphasize something: Confidence doesn’t mean knowing with absolute certainty that you’ve made the perfect choice.
That’s an unrealistic standard, and arguably one of the biggest contributors to indecision in the first place!
You can make a thoughtful, informed, values-aligned decision and still have some uncertainty about what will happen next.
Confidence is about recognizing that you’ve done the work, considered what matters, and are willing to move forward with the choice you’ve made.
It’s also about accepting that you can handle the outcome, even if it doesn’t unfold exactly as you’d hoped.
Here’s what those final decisions might look like in my little test-case scenarios:
I’m going to eat here and order these items.
I know it’s my decision to make. I’ve considered what I’m in the mood for, what my options are, and what matters to me today.
If I don’t enjoy it, I don’t have to eat here again. No big deal.
I’m comfortable with my choice, and I’m going to enjoy my meal!
I’ve decided I want to see this person again.
I enjoyed our first date, I’m interested in learning more about them, and I haven’t identified anything that makes me genuinely uncomfortable or incompatible with what I’m looking for.
It’s fine if I don’t know whether this person will eventually become my partner. I just need to feel comfortable choosing another date.
And if things don’t work out? That’s okay, too!
I’ve considered my financial situation, explored my alternatives, identified what matters most to me, and decided that leaving is the right next step.
I might not know exactly what comes next, and I can’t guarantee that everything will work out as planned.
But I’ve made this decision based on the information available to me and the priorities I’ve identified for myself.
I’m comfortable taking responsibility for this choice, and I’m ready to move forward.
That’s Confidence.
Not the absence of uncertainty, but the willingness to make a decision.
One of the things I like most about my framework is that it doesn’t have to be complicated.
For everyday decisions, like what to eat, it might be enough to mentally walk through the four steps:
Control: Is this my decision to make?
Clarity: What do I know, and what else do I need to know?
Compass: What matters most to me here?
Confidence: What am I choosing, and am I ready to move forward?
For more consequential decisions, it might be helpful to journal through each step, write down your thoughts, or revisit your answers as you gather more information.
You also don’t necessarily need to move through the steps in a perfectly linear fashion. Sometimes, identifying your priorities in Compass will reveal that you need more information in Clarity. Sometimes, Confidence will prompt you to reconsider whether you’re actually in control of the decision.
The point isn’t to create another rigid set of rules to follow. It’s to give yourself a structure that helps you think more intentionally, question your assumptions, and make decisions that feel like your own.
Control prevents you from taking responsibility for things that aren’t yours.
Clarity prevents you from making decisions based on misinformation or unexamined assumptions.
Compass prevents you from prioritizing things that don’t actually matter to you.
Confidence prevents you from getting stuck trying to guarantee an outcome.
So if you’ve liked this framework and idea, here’s some fun news: I’ve also been working on something that takes this philosophy even further (and more practical!).
I’m developing a philosophy companion app: a place to create, organize, revisit, and remind yourself of your personal philosophy, including your values, goals, principles, and convictions.
The idea is to have a resource that helps you understand what you believe, why you believe it, and how you want those beliefs to influence the way you live.
So what about FourCight? Well, I’m also planning to incorporate a decision-making portal and journal based on this FourCight Method, so you can work through decisions whenever you need a little more clarity, direction, or confidence.
And I’d love to know if this is something other people would find useful, too.
I’m particularly interested in hearing from people who struggle with overthinking, decision fatigue, or figuring out what they actually want outside of what they’ve been told they should want.
Would you be interested in testing the app or receiving updates as it develops?
If so, I’d love for you to fill out this short form: Help Shape A Personal Philosophy App
I started building this for myself, but if it can help other people make more intentional decisions and create lives that actually fit, even better!!
In the meantime, remember:
Question inherited rules. Listen to yourself. Create a life that fits.
All the love,
Imani